Get in touch. Contact us or request a meeting.

I'd like to schedule a meeting.
Sending message...

Hellmuth & Johnson

8050 West 78th Street, Minneapolis, MN 55439
LOCAL 952-941-4005
FREE 888-343-3918
FAX 952-941-2337

Subscribe. Join our mailing list.

Community Association
Family Law
IT & eCommerce
Real Estate


Transmission of information to H&J via this form does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential information should not be sent through this form.

Accept    Decline

Hellmuth & Johnson Gains Court Support for Deposition Requests of Former Microsoft Executives


EDINA, MN – In the ongoing Canadian litigation case of Pro Sys Consultants & Neil Godfrey v. Microsoft Corporation, Pro Sys Consultants has been granted an order that obligates two former Microsoft executives, Steve Ballmer and James Allchin, to participate in depositions. This order was granted after Microsoft Corporation (“Microsoft”) made multiple motions to quash and for a protective order, but the Court (United States District Court Western District of Washington at Seattle) denied the motions.

“The Pro Sys Consultants case concerns allegations that Microsoft engaged in anticompetitive conduct relating to its operating systems, middleware, and PC compatible applications.” The plaintiffs (Pro Sys Consultants & Neil Godfrey) “requested that Microsoft produce several of its former executives for trial”, and Microsoft refused. The plaintiffs are now seeking to depose former Microsoft employees: James Allchin and Steve Ballmer.

James Allchin was employed by Microsoft until early 2007, serving as an executive and leading several projects, including the development of Microsoft’s operating systems (such as Windows Vista). The plaintiffs subpoena seeks his testimony on “the tying of Internet Explorer and other products to Windows” and its effect on competing products for the time period of 2006-2013. Steve Ballmer worked for Microsoft from June 1980 until February 2014, and served as CEO from January 2000 until he left the company. The plaintiffs seek his testimony on “the competitive landscape in the operating systems, browser, and office productivity markets; Microsoft’s strategic decisions with respect to Microsoft Windows, Internet Explorer, and Office; [and] the effect of Microsoft’s decisions on competing products.”  Significant amounts of files produced by Microsoft in the case came from Mr. Allchin’s and Mr. Ballmer’s custodian files or files that they were the author or recipient of.

Hellmuth & Johnson, PLLC offers a range of legal services to meet both corporate and individual needs.  Named among Minnesota's 25 largest law firms, Hellmuth & Johnson holds the highest possible Peer Review Rating from Martindale-Hubbell — the AV® Peer Review Rated designation. 

See In re Pro-Sys Consultants and Neil Godfrey, No. 16-00459, Dkt. No. 34 (W.D. Wash. 2016).

# # #